Vesuvio’s Pizza

Reviews

• Melanie S.

  star star star star star 1 June 2026

  Best NY Pizza in Florida and beyond!
  
  We are pizza snobs. We like it a certain way and can barely ever find it. We usually ordered from New York Pizza and Pasta. One night we ordered one pizza from both places to simply test them both against each other.
  
  Vesuvio's was done first and was hot and fresh. The other was ready 45 minutes later! You could tell Tony's ingredients were fresh and good quality. When the pepperoni curl and the grease puddles - you know it's gonna be good.
  
  We ordered from him probably 20 more times in the three months we stayed. If you eat in don't expect to be waited on hand and foot. Go there to enjoy your company and an amazing pizza. He is very busy and is usually alone or with just one other person. We always ordered Togo and chatted for just a few minutes each time. He's a great guy that makes THE BEST NY Style Pizza.

• Joshua P.

  star star star star star 31 May 2026

  Good Pizza! So glad I looked at google reviews, as these reviews on yelp were a little unfair. The place is mainly for to-go orders, so I understand how some of the reviews may feel the service is lacking but give the guy a break, his main job is to cook pizza and get them ready for to go orders. Anyways I had a great experience and a couple laughs with the owner and his compadre when I stopped in.
  
  Anyways onto the pizza, it's pretty good! I had the special minus peppers (I'd rather sub hot peppers than green) I'd say top 3 pizza joints in north Naples area and will be in my rotation of L'appetito, The Crust and now Visuvios. And funny thing is I'm a thin crust guy! But something about the taste combo here looked past my crust preference which visuvios was more fluffy than a heavy thicker crust but still thicker than the foldable new you're slices you'd think about. Either way was a solid pizza joint! Cheers/Skol!

• Brian K.

  star star star star star 23 May 2026

  It's hard to find good pizza in sw florida.
  Coming from nj and ny we know good pie.
  This place is superior to any pizza we have tried from ft Myers to Marco. The crust is tender chew without being touch, the toppings are fresh, great flavor.

• Carolle G.

  star star star star_border star_border 15 May 2026

  We ordered a pepperoni/sausage pizza for carryout. I felt that it was kind of greasy. It tasted okay. The crust was thin and hand tossed. The sausage was cut like the pepperoni which I had never had before. All around it was just okay. Probably won't order again.

• Courtney S.

  star star star star star 6 May 2026

  Really amazing pizza, the sauce is perfect and not sweet at all! Real small semi spicy pepperonis as well! Fried raviolis are yummy as well!